Facebook has confirmed that it has been paying third party contractors to transcribe user conversations that they recorded in secret.
An investigation by has revealed hundreds of minutes of Facebook Messenger conversations were provided to human transcribers who had no knowledge of what the content was or how it was obtained.
In 2015, Facebook introduced an opt-in voice-to-text transcription service in their Messenger app. Users were led to believe the transcriptions were performed by machines and no humans were privy to their conversations.
In a statement released this week, however, a Facebook spokesperson confirmed that the company has been outsourcing selected transcription orders to humans. The service has now been suspended.
Facebook claims that the purpose of the human review was to ensure that their machine-transcription service was working correctly.
Workers at the third party company who confirmed the recordings to Bloomberg did so under the condition of anonymity for fear of losing their jobs.
They reported the conversations given to them sometimes contained vulgar language and they were not told why they needed to be transcribed.
Earlier in the year, in a US Senate inquiry, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg denied the longstanding rumor that Messenger was listening to conversations.
Listening in
Facebook is the latest in a long line of tech giants to come under fire for recording users' conversations without express permission.
In early August, announced that it was adding a ‘no human review’ option to its Alexa AI product after it was revealed that audio recordings were being provided to human transcribers.
The Alexa Terms and Conditions did not make mention of audio clips being provided to human transcribers.
In July, that more than 1,000 audio snippets taken from their Assistant feature had been leaked by its partners to a Belgian news outlet who were then able to identify people by their voices.
German privacy watchdog The Hamburg Data Protection Authority ordered Google to cease the recordings, to which the company confirmed that they had halted the practice in late July.
Apple was also forced to defend giving Siri audio clips to contractors after a whistleblower told that they had heard snippets of “confidential medical information, drug deals, and recordings of couples having sex.”
The company said that “less than one per cent” of daily Siri activation recordings are given to human analysts.
